Are you in a dilemma on PMI ACP vs CSM and unable to decide which is the right choice? You will be better equipped to make an informed decision after reading this. So here we go, exploring PMI ACP vs CSM, what they are, where they are used and their pros and cons. Jump in for understanding and assessing PMI ACP vs CSM!
Why Agile Project Manager Certification?
Here are a few benefits of agile certification irrespective of what choice you make in the PMI ACP vs CSM:
- Agile is the growing trend in project management
- In addition to project manager role, you can also look for a scrum master, business analyst, agile trainer, etc.
- The salary survey from PMI states that a PMI ACP certified individual draws 20% more salary compared to the non-certified person.
- Salaries for various roles vary between $122554 to $163339 on an average
PMI ACP vs CSM: Definitions
What is PMI ACP?
PMI ACP is the most acclaimed credential for Agile practices. The Agile Certified Practitioner is a project management certification that comes from PMI Institute.
What is PMI?
PMI has been the number 1 organization for project management across all the continents from the last 50 years almost. PMI institute advocates project management best practices, and promotes research and education in project management. PMBOK or the Project Management Body of Knowledge is the de facto standard for project management worldwide and its agile extension is the reference for many organizations. The generic project management certification, PMP certification is the gold standard of project management. You can explore this certificate in How to Get PMP Certification blog article.
PMI is headquartered in Pennsylvania, USA. Though started in the USA, currently PMI has its chapters and offices in all the continents with a member base of 450,000 project managers and a total of 280 chapters spread across the globe.
PMI has been catering to about 2.9 million professionals in project management space, adding value. You can see the mammoth reach of PMI and the number of years it has been standing for the project management profession and the trust project managers and industry have in it. Therefore, it is obvious that a project manager certification from an organization of this size and reach will go a long way in your career.
The exemplary service that PMI does in project management tilts the balance in favor of PMI ACP in the PMI ACP vs CSM discussion. Let us delve deeper to analyze PMI ACP Vs CSM so that you can arrive at which one is for you!
What is CSM?
Before we compare and contrast PMI ACP vs CSM, let us see what CSM is. CSM stands for Certified Scrum Master (CSM). This certification is focused exclusively on Scrum methodology in Agile principles and practices. CSM credential comes from Scrum Alliance – a not for profit organization established in 2001 for agile community.
If you are not aware, Agile has many flavors such as Scrum, Kanban, Extreme programming, etc. Therefore, when you are analyzing PMI ACP vs CSM, one point to note is that when you go for CSM, you would be certified only in Scrum methodology of doing agile projects.
In addition to CSM which is akin to PMI ACP, if you are a software developer, you could showcase your scrum project ability by going for the Certified Scrum Developer (CSD). There are also Certified Scrum Product Owner (CSPO) and Certified Scrum Professional (CSP). In Scrum Alliance, a different certification is needed for each role.
Who should go for CSM?
Are you working in an organization that uses Scrum methodology to deliver their projects? Do you want to advance your career prospects by adding a credential on scrum values, practices, and applications and demonstrate that you have more knowledge and expertise compared to other project managers? If yes, CSM is the basic certification for the scrum that you can start with.
PMI ACP vs CSM: Who can go for these?
Should you go for PMI ACP certification or CSM certification? Are there any prerequisites? Which role will the PMI ACP benefit? What are the PMI ACP Requirements and what does CSM require? Would you be eligible for these?
- If you are working in a company that imbibes agile methodology, then you can plan for PMI ACP Certification exam or a CSM
- Next, if you have been one of a close-knit team working on a project using agile principles, then an agile credential is definitely an asset
- You have heard everyone’s moving towards an agile environment Therefore, you are curious as to what this is? Hence, you want to understand what agile practices are all about?
- Do you want to be recognized for your experience and knowledge of agile methodology?
Currently, what is your role? Do you fit into any of these roles given below? It seems imperative that your survival is at stake if you don’t have an agile certification whichever role you are in. Hence, it is essential that you understand the PMI ACP Vs CSM completely. Are you working in any of the following roles?
- Project managers
- Associate/Asst. Manager – Projects
- Team leads/Managers
- Project Executives/Engineers
- Software Developers
- Any professional aspiring to be an Agile Project Management Professional
The post is useful if you are working in one of the above capacities or aspiring to take one of those roles.
PMI ACP vs CSM: Eligibility Requirements
For you to take a call on PMI ACP vs CSM, you also need to know their prerequisites. Let us start with PMI ACP Requirements. By analyzing these, you would know which one is for you in the PMI ACP vs CSM.
PMI ensures that there is a judicious mix of education and experience along with formal training to be eligible to appear for the PMI ACP Certification exam. Here they are:
|Educational Qualification||high school diploma/secondary degree/associate’s degree|
|General project experience||2000 hours working in a team in projects|
|Agile project experience||Worked for 1500 hours on teams that used agile methodology|
|Training on Agile Methodology||21-hour training on agile practices|
CSM Eligibility requirements
While PMI ACP credential needs the above prerequisites to be fulfilled, CSM certification does not prescribe any specific education or experience. However, for CSM you need to first undergo a CSM course from a Certified Scrum Trainer (CST). The CSM course you need to attend is an in-person, two-day (16 hour) program taught by a Certified Scrum Trainer (CST).
PMI ACP vs CSM: Process of Certification
How do you go about getting the PMI ACP Certification or CSM certification? What is the process involved? To make an informed decision, you need to know all aspects of PMI ACP certification and CSM. We have discussed the eligibility requirements for both certifications. Hence, let us move on to the process of certification. After that, we will explore the exam that you need to take for earning the PMI ACP vs CSM credential. Based on this information, we can formulate the pros and cons of PMI ACP vs CSM.
PMI ACP Certification Process
Here are the steps for becoming PMI ACP certified which will tell you How to become ACP:
You start by checking if you are eligible. If you meet the PMI ACP requirements, you take the Online ACP Training or a classroom one. Then you apply online, pay fees and fix a date for the exam while preparing using a PMI ACP study guide in parallel. Then, you go to a Pearson VUE test center and take the test. Once you are certified, you need to maintain the credential by earning PDUs or Professional Development Units.
CSM Certification Process
Here are the steps involved in the CSM certification:
- Take the 2-day scrum training
- After the course, you need to register online for the Scrum Master Accredited Certification Program within 3 months after attending the course
- When you complete the online registration, you will get your Exam Access Code
- Take the online test
- Become a Certified Scrum Master
PMI ACP vs CSM: Exam
Here is a comparison of the PMI ACP vs CSM certification exam, the duration, number of questions and mode of test
|Duration of exam||3 hours||1 hour|
|Number of questions||120||50|
|Type of questions||Multiple choice||Multiple choice|
|Place of test||Pearson VUE center||online|
PMI ACP vs CSM: Pros and Cons
At the outset, it may appear to you that the CSM is simpler but you may also want to look at the pros and cons of PMI ACP vs CSM before you jump to any conclusions. Let us look at the plus and minus of PMI ACP and CSM by analyzing the PMI ACP vs CSM.
|PMI ACP is the credential offered by the Project management institute that has been instituted about half a century ago. PMI has been advocating project management from the last 50 years and has more credibility as the number one organization for project management||CSM is the credential being offered by the Scrum Alliance formed in 2001, about a decade and a half ago|
|PMI ACP tests not just your theoretical concepts on agile but also gives substantial importance to your experience in managing projects both agile and general. Therefore, PMI ACP credential has a more comprehensive assessment of both theory and practice||CSM does not need any practical experience and tests only the scrum flavor of agile. It is entirely concept based.|
|If you have PMI ACP credential, you are certified to have knowledge on various agile practices such as Scrum, Kanban, Extreme Programming or XP, Test Driven Development or TDD, Lean, Dynamic Systems Development Method or DSDM, etc.||IF you have CSM credential, you are only known as having better knowledge on Scrum methodology in agile but you are not exposed to other variants in agile practices that are used across the industry. This may limit your options to only scrum methodology of agile project management.|
|While the 21-hour training on agile practices can be taken as a classroom session, it can also be taken as a PMI ACP online training. PMI ACP online training saves you time, cost and gives the flexibility to do it anywhere anytime.||For CSM, in person, classroom training of 16 hours or 2 days is a mandatory prerequisite. Finding a course that fits your availability could be a challenge. Moreover, you do not have flexibility and may involve travel and a complete 2-day dedication for the course.|
|You can get the PMI ACP online training for about $200. If you compare with the CSM training cost, it is a huge saving in the overall cost||CSM in-person course of 2 –days costs you on an average $1000|
|PMI ACP certification costs about $495 or $574 with membership.||CSM certification would cost you the course fee which generally includes the exam fee. The trainer pays the fee to the Scrum Alliance. While a few institutes charge you an extra fee. However, the total cost could be between $800-$1200.|
|PMI ACP can be taken by project managers, product owners, developers, testers, business analysts, or even trainers and coaches in Agile methodology. In fact it is a comprehensive certification that fits any of these roles for understanding and demonstrating their knowledge of various agile practices||CSM is for Scrum Master or, a team member and is anentry-levell certification in agile scrum. There are different certifications for different roles such as CSPO for Product Owners, CSD for Developers or a CSP which makes you a certified scrum professional. Therefore, every role has a different certification|
|PMI ACP has wider coverage, thorough and needs dedicated effort ad equally rewarding. Since industry knows the value of the effort you have put in and PMI’s expertise, it will be given due credit||CSM seems simple to get and more chances of clearing but the key factor is CSM is meant only for Scrum methodology and industry knows the effort needed for the certification. Hence, the credit for this is proportionate unless your organization is only concerned about Scrum.|
PMI ACP vs CSM: Exam content
Whichever you choose between PMI ACP vs CSM, you need to be aware of what you will be assessed upon. Let us look at the topics that you should be knowledgeable for the exam. Since these would be the assessment topics, naturally your training for either PMI ACP or CSM should include the relevant content. Here are the topics for you to decide on the PMI ACP vs CSM
PMI ACP exam coverage
When you appear for the PMI ACP, you should be aware of the seven domains and its associated tools and techniques which are:
7 domains in PMI ACP
- Agile principles and mindset
- Value driven delivery
- Stakeholder engagement
- Team performance
- Adaptive planning
- Problem detection and resolution
- Continuous improvement
CSM Exam Coverage
What about CSM? What topics would be part of this credential assessment?
- Scrum roles
- Scrum history and basics
- Product backlogs
- Planning releases and sprints
- Problems that can arise while implementing scrum methods
- Scrum scalability
- Conducting meetings, including the daily scrum
- Creating tasks and reports
- Team Organization and Building
Let’s summarize the pros and cons of PMI ACP vs CSM,
- While PMI ACP certification has edge in terms of the overall assessment showcasing a holistic understanding of agile environment, CSM lacks in the practical aspect in the PMI ACP vs CSM comparison
- The training on agile practices is mandatory in both PMI ACP and CSM. Flexibility with ACP Certification Training Online gives it an edge in the tussle PMI ACP vs CSM
- From a cost angle in PMI ACP vs CSM options, the winner is PMI ACP
- While the duration of the exam and number of questions are lower in CSM, you are getting the breadth of knowledge with PMI ACP. PMI ACP exam covers different agile methodologies and hence you have wider exposure and not limited to scrum which is the case in CSM
- Scrum alliance website states that A CSM Course is Only the First Step and becoming agile needs dedication and continuous commitment. On the other hand, PMI says by becoming PMI ACP you are demonstrating a certain level of professionalism in Agile project management.
- In your tryst with PMI ACP vs CSM, you need to be aware that while CSM is focused on the Software industry, PMI ACP has wider application with more number of agile methods and being industry independent. Hence, if you are a PMI ACP, you can work in any industry that runs projects using agile methodology not necessarily only software development.
You have all the ammunition on PMI ACP vs CSM to decide which gives you better value in the long run and as you have seen PMI ACP coming from PMI has more mileage and standing across the industries while CSM limits to IT industry only.
Sunanda Gundavajhala, B.Tech, M.B.A, PMP has over 25 years of project management. She is a consultant, trainer on project management for different sectors and is the recipient of “Recognition of Excellence” award from PMI, USA and Woman Volunteer award from Hyderabad, India Chapter of PMI. She has contributed to the “Practice Standard on Scheduling, PMI” in addition to being the Liaison officer for PMIEF (Education Foundation) for the Hyderabad, India Chapter of PMI